Woohoo! Back to blogging with a bang! I read through all of the Maize cohort's Connections Across Disciplines assignments and although they were all very well done, I had to choose one to write about. I ended up choosing the Biology group's "BYOD-to-Discover-Tree-Species" because they took such a different approach than my group did. The Biology group gave an excellent example of how students using their own technology could benefit a Biology classroom. The students would go out into the woods and take pictures of different tree species. The use of technology is beneficial here because students can document their observations in a quicker and more accurate way than, for example, drawing out each species they find.
I really liked that this group addressed how they would handle if students did not each have their own device. Each group only needed to have one device so it is likely that there would be enough student's with electronic devices that this would work out. I liked this lesson plan because it was very hands on. The students got to go outside and interact with nature which for a generation of students so technology-focused, going out in nature may be a rare encounter for them. It also showed them how technology can actually help bring them close to nature as this app "Leafsnap" could be used as an electronic field guide to identify tree species. This was a nice contrast to the usual use of technology that brings students farther away from nature.
The group referenced the success of the field trips at Scarlett Middle School during the summer program that were successful in having the students engage actively with nature. I liked this connection and their continued focus on bringing students outside in order to learn more about the world around them. Due to the unique aspect of this lesson where students would go outside instead of staying in the classroom, I would have liked to see a bit more maybe about how the group thought about how they would talk about appropriate behavior before students went out into the woods. Before going out into the woods at Scarlett we always discussed with out students how important it is to respect nature and how much more you would see and observe if you are quiet. The group did discuss how it is important to use all 5 senses which I liked a lot!
Overall, I think the Biology group came up with a great lesson and I think it would function well in either middle school or high school. Students these days do not interact with nature as much as past generations did and this is detrimental to their development in general and detrimental to the formation of their relationship with the natural world.

Betsy Rae! Thank you for sharing a summary and your thoughts on this particular BYOD lesson. I had not read this when deciding what to write my post about, and I remember a personal conversation with you in which you gave this high praise. I have to say, it does sound like a really good lesson. I think you summed it up best when you said "This was a nice contrast to the usual use of technology that brings students farther away from nature." I agree with your appreciation that not all students would be required to have/use their own device for this project. That is a very real obstacle to the notion of BYOD in the classroom. This group seems to have considered that as well. I also thought of our work at Scarlett while reading your post. It's interesting to think how much more some of our students would have engaged with nature if they were given the option of taking pictures of it. Everyone is a photographer with a camera in their hands!
ReplyDeleteKeep on keeping on,
Jimmy
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteBetsy, I'm so glad you enjoyed our BYOD lesson and thanks for the positive feedback! I really appreciate your comment about the (hopefully) simplicity of the technology. One of our goals was to provide a lesson where students would not be limited by their personal technology. We specifically chose a tech tool that would be accessible to all students and a cell phone seemed to be the most logical choice. Also, I'm glad you noticed that Scarlett also was an inspiration for our lesson. We felt that students would be more engaged outside of the classroom and felt that the hands on experience with nature would be appropriate. You also made a great point about classroom management. I'll have to admit I didn't even think of this issue until I read your post. Now that I have more field experience, I do realize how important it is with students to be explicit about expectations. Thanks for giving me a helpful teaching hint for the future.
ReplyDeleteHey Betsy,
ReplyDeleteYou gave an awesome summary and analysis of this lesson! Like you, I found this lesson to be very different from the one my own group developed. I really like the way your analysis doesn't get bogged down in the technological aspects of the lesson, but rather you probe further and assess it's potential to be "hands on" and "engaging". This is important because the use of technology does not necessarily mean that the lesson will be either of those things. However, I agree that this lesson succeeds in using technology successfully and I liked that you noted that "The use of technology is beneficial here because students can document their observations in a quicker and more accurate way than, for example, drawing out each species they find." I also like that you assess the lesson's probable success in both a middle and high school classroom! Thanks for sharing your thoughts!
Samantha